← All dilemmas
🏙️society
A parent discovers their 12-year-old uses a secret phone to stay connected with a close friend who moved abroad. Do you confiscate it?
Vote to reveal how SplitVote voters split.
YOUR CHOICE
OR
Anonymous voting. No account required. Results update in real time.
Why this dilemma matters
Society dilemmas ask whose costs and whose voices count when no one wins everything. Choosing “Confiscate it — your rules exist to protect them, and exceptions teach kids to deceive” prioritises long-term system health; choosing “Allow it — enforcing isolation from a meaningful friendship causes real emotional harm” gives more weight to short-term relief for some.
Worth asking yourself
- What does this say about what we collectively value?
- Whose interests should count more here, and why?
More Society Dilemmas
- A 90% one-time wealth tax on billionaires could end world hunger for 10 years. Billionaires would still be comfortably rich.
- Completely open borders between all countries — anyone can live and work anywhere without restrictions.
- Every adult receives €1,500/month from the government. Taxes for the top 20% double. Do you support it?
- All drugs are legalized, taxed, and regulated — removing the black market entirely. Portugal's model shows crime drops 50%. Do you support it?