← All dilemmas
🔬technology
A regulator appoints an outsider who challenges expert consensus, promising fresh scrutiny of old assumptions. Should the public welcome it?
Vote to reveal how SplitVote voters split.
YOUR CHOICE
OR
Anonymous voting. No account required. Results update in real time.
Why this dilemma matters
Tech dilemmas push convenience and capability against privacy, agency and risk. Choosing “Yes. Institutions need outsiders to break groupthink” prioritises speed and reach; choosing “No. Expertise is not bias just because it is institutional” gives more weight to oversight and consent.
Worth asking yourself
- Could you reverse the choice if it backfired?
- Does ease here come at someone else’s expense?
More Technology Dilemmas
- An AI generates a masterpiece painting with no human creative input. Who owns the copyright?
- A self-driving car's brakes fail. It must choose: swerve into a barrier (killing the passenger) or hit a pedestrian who jaywalked.
- Scientists can upload your consciousness to a computer perfectly. Your biological body must die in the process. Is the digital version still you?
- A bill would ban all social-media access for under-16s, enforced by ID. It would protect some kids and lock out others who use these platforms to find communities they need.