← All dilemmas
⚖️justice
A student worked harder than anyone but still failed. Another barely tried and aced it. Both can only pass one. Who deserves it?
Vote to reveal how SplitVote voters split.
YOUR CHOICE
OR
Anonymous voting. No account required. Results update in real time.
Why this dilemma matters
These dilemmas put rules and circumstances against each other and demand a verdict. Choosing “Pass the hard worker — sustained effort is what education should reward” prioritises the letter of the law; choosing “Pass the high scorer — outcomes are the only fair, objective measure” gives more weight to the spirit behind it.
Worth asking yourself
- Is mercy a kind of justice here, or its opposite?
- Would you apply the same standard to yourself?
More Justice Dilemmas
- A new tax would halve the income of the top 1% and double the income of the bottom 20%. The total wealth in society stays the same.
- An AI sentencing tool is more consistent than human judges across similar cases, but cannot explain its reasoning. Should it be used?
- You are a juror. Every piece of evidence says guilty — but your gut tells you the defendant is innocent. The jury must be unanimous.
- DNA evidence exonerates an innocent person after 25 years on death row. The real killer is 85, frail, and dying. Do they go to prison?