Hard Would You Rather Questions That Actually Make You Think
Most "would you rather" questions are trivially easy — would you rather be rich or famous, fly or be invisible. The hard ones are different. They are hard precisely because both options are genuinely bad, and refusing to choose is its own kind of answer. Psychologists who study moral cognition call this a "genuine dilemma": a situation where every path forward sacrifices something you care about, and the sacrifice is irreversible. These questions do not test your imagination; they test the shape of your values — which commitments you will protect when protection comes at a price. The scenarios below have no correct answer. They have your answer, and someone else's, and the gap between them is worth understanding.
Vote on this dilemma
A lifeboat holds 8. There are 9 of you. Nobody volunteers. Someone proposes the eldest goes — they look at you and nod.
4 votes cast
Research background
Psychologist Joshua Greene at Harvard's Moral Cognition Lab has shown through fMRI studies that genuinely difficult dilemmas — those where utilitarian and deontological intuitions conflict — activate distinct neural systems, producing measurable response-time delays and higher reported distress. Separately, Fiery Cushman's work on model-based versus habitual moral judgment at the same lab suggests that hard binary choices disrupt automatic responding and force deliberate reasoning, which is why they feel cognitively costly in a way that easy choices do not.
- An fMRI investigation of emotional engagement in moral judgment — Harvard University / Science
- Action, outcome, and value: A dual-system framework for morality — Harvard University / Personality and Social Psychology Review
SplitVote is for entertainment and aggregate insight, not a scientific test.
Related dilemmas
A runaway trolley is heading toward 5 people. You can pull a lever to divert it — but it will kill 1 person instead.
You are a doctor. One healthy patient's organs could save the lives of 5 people dying in the next room. No one would ever know.
Your group of 13 reaches a fortified shelter — already occupied by 8 strangers at capacity. They refuse to open. Your group includes children. You could force the door; they have no weapons.
Your terminally ill parent is in unbearable pain and begs you to end their suffering. The doctors say weeks remain. No one will find out.
Related topics
No account required. Your vote is anonymous.